Choosing between the two will largely depend on the drummer's skill level, preferences, and budget. The TD-17KV2 is an excellent mid-range choice, with features that suit both beginners and advanced players seeking a portable, versatile option at a remarkable price. However, if budget isn't a constraint and you're seeking a more immersive drumming experience with larger pad sizes and more advanced sound modeling, the TD-50KV2, belonging to Roland's high-end range, would be the go-to choice.
Roland TD-17KV2 vs Roland TD-50KV2 V-Drums (2024) Head to Head
The Roland TD-17KV2 and TD-50KV2 V-Drums stand as paragons of excellence in 2023. These two drum sets, hailing from the reputable house of Roland, have been designed with precision and cutting-edge technology to offer unparalleled drumming experiences.
Both models cater to diverse skill levels and musical styles, boasting unique features such as different drum modules, varied kick types, and distinct pad sizes. From the convenience of Bluetooth connectivity in the TD-17KV2 to the advanced technology embodied in the TD-50X module of the TD-50KV2, these sets redefine drumming aesthetics, keeping the rhythm alive in the digital age.
Key Differences
The TD-50X is more feature-packed and much more versatile, offering more than 900 sounds compared to the 310 sounds of the TD-17, making it a great choice for drummers who want to play different genres and experiment with different sounds. Plus, the TD-50KV2 provides more effects such as compressor, EQ, overhead mic simulator, and room-reverb, while the TD-17KV2 effect choices are more limited.
Regarding additional features, TD-17KV2 offers Bluetooth connectivity for wirelessly streaming audio (backing tracks) from your smartphone to the module, while the TD-50KV2 does not.
On the physical side, the TD-17KV2 has a tower-style kick, whereas the TD-50KV2 V-Drums comes with a full-sized kick drum for a fully authentic acoustic drum-playing experience.
The TD-50KV2 V-Drums have larger hi-hat, ride, crash, tom, and snare pads, offering better and more realistic playability.
Also, the TD-50KV2 V-Drums has an extra tom and crash compared to the TD-17KV2, making the kit more professional and versatile.
The snare of the TD-17KV2 is mounted to a rack while the TD-50KV2 snare comes with an acoustic stand, giving a more realistic experience and freedom to position the snare as you like.
The TD-17KV2 offers two additional pad-cymbal inputs to enlarge your kit whenever you want. On the other hand, the TD-50KV2 features four inputs, offering more flexibility to enlarge your kit.
The TD-50KV2 is significantly higher priced than the TD-17KV2.
The Roland TD-17KV2 is equipped with the TD-17, while the Roland TD-50KV2 V-Drums uses the TD-50X.
Key Features in Common
There are some common features between these kits as well, especially regarding the drum module.
Both kits offer MIDI connectivity via USB or a 5-pin MIDI port to use the kit as a MIDI controller using the VST instruments from your computer.
Both kits feature audio-over-USB capability, meaning that you can record connected to a computer via USB without the need for an audio interface.
Both drum modules offer a custom sampling feature with an SD card so that you can use your own custom sound samples from an SD card.
Check out the Roland TD-17KV2 in action.
And here's a video of the Roland TD-50KV2 V-Drums.
Price Comparison Between The Roland TD-17KV2 and Roland TD-50KV2 V-Drums
Use the below to get up-to-date prices for both the Roland TD-17KV2 and Roland TD-50KV2 V-Drums
Hi-Hat
Cymbal Pads
Toms
Drum Module
Snare
Kick
Overview
Verdict
The TD-17KV2 and TD-50KV2 demonstrate Roland's commitment to quality and versatility. While the TD-17KV2's price, compact design, and Bluetooth capabilities make it an excellent choice for intermediate drummers and those who require mobility, the TD-50KV2 is targeted at pros desiring superior sound modeling, larger pads, and the feel of a full-sized kick drum. Your decision will ultimately depend on your specific needs, budget, and preferences.
Berk Oztuna